This is the P2PU Archive. If you want the current site, go to www.p2pu.org!
P2PU Lounge - Mar 2010
How to Change Your Message Notification Settings (all users)
http://wiki.p2pu.org/course-page-administration
Users can configure their notification settings in two ways: (1) Define what events trigger notification emails (2) Frequency of the messages
(1) Events
You can decide what events (for example, the submission of an assignment) should trigger an email notification. The user interface for doing that is not completely intuitive yet, but the functionality should work:
-
Go to your user page (for Niels this would be http://p2pu.org/users/niels, but you have to go to your own page for this to work)
-
Click the "Notifications" tab
-
Click on the link "Administer your subscriptions" to see what notifications you already have (and change them), or
-
Click on the link "Content type in group" (and don't pause to wonder what that means) to add a new notification
-
Make sure to save any changes you made
(2) Frequency
You can set the frequency that the p2pu site sends you notification of changes made to the courses you are a member of. This will help you control the amount of email coming to you.
-
Go into your Account.
-
Choose the Edit tab.
-
Scroll down until you see the Message and Notification setting panel.
-
Change your Default Send Interval – you can choose to receive notifications immediately, every hour, twice a day, daily or weekly. We suggest you choose at least daily, since important messages come through your notifications.
-
Scroll down and hit save.
Another way to make these changes is via the notification emails you may have already recieved. At the foot of those mails, you should see a small note that says "This is an automatic message from p2pu. To manage your subscriptions, browse to http://p2pu.org/user/somethingblahblah". Just click on that link, and you'll automatically be taken to your notification and subscription page, where you can make the changes.
Comments
Drupal messaging & notifications
I'm really concerned that we, as students, only get notifications from teachers, and do not get notified when a reply is given to a peer comment.
(I note a discussion in the "Lounge" about low engagement of students: http://p2pu.org/node/809/discussions/3079). Perhaps this is part of the reason?)
Organic Groups provides auto-subscribe functionality as default for forums, and additionally comment-notify and subscriptions modules can easily be configured to allow a peer to subscribe to any thread.
The site, unfortunately is not working intuitively yet; and even as a web developer who has used Drupal for years, I'm really battling to find my way back to comments I submitted as peer review of other student's work.
Perhaps I might be missing something, because trawling the Dashboard to retrieve a thread seems highly counter-intuitive.
Bravo, Jeff. This site is
Bravo, Jeff. This site is amazingly hard and counterintuitive for someone who has no experience in computer programming or developping. While I have a great deal of experience on computers [ever since the first Mac/Apple], nothing seems to help when I am looking to find out where and if my fellow students have commented on assignments!
So far, I have been wondering why we were encouraged to sign up for the lounge...
Co-sign. RSS feeds for
Co-sign. RSS feeds for comment threads would be nice, or at least some indication in the thread menu on the left that there are new posts (and how many) would be a great start.
+1 | The "Recent comments"
+1 | The "Recent comments" block in Drupal should work pretty well for that; and will focus on "groups" by default. At this point we'd also get the lounge comments - which is okay - despite the fact we do actually get email notifications there.
Your suggestion is an excellent (imho) interim solution. Thank you.
Thanks for all the suggestions!
Thanks for all the comments. I wholeheartedly agree - the comments and collaboration features need to be improved. We are working on it, and I'll forward your suggestions to the developers. A few questions / thoughts:
* I am subscribed to a two courses to see how things work. In both of these courses, I receive email alerts if someone adds a comment in the discussion topic. Please follow up separately with me (using the contact form on my home page) if you are not receiving these alerts for comments.
* If anyone would like to get an account on the task/bug/feature tracker to help with the development process, please let me know and we'll get you set up.
* Another thing I personally would like to see changed is the comment process. I would prefer a blog style comment system - where the comment field simply appears at the bottom of the page, but you can see all previous comments as you are typing yours. If others have thoughts on this, please respond here.
Thanks again for all the suggestions. This is the first time we are running courses on this platform, and some things are still very rough. I know this is causing some frustration and can only assure you that we are trying hard to collect feedback and respond to it by making changes to the site as soon as we can.
Comments
In my limited experience so far: to avoid preconceptions from reading other student's reviews first, it is preferable to have comments on a separate page with only the comment/topic to which you're responding.
To further that end, notifications should just provide the subject, poster's name, and the URL; and not the comment body.
Update - notifications are fixed
Hey Jeff: We updated the notifications settings. All course members should now get notifications for the most important activities (documents, discussion, assignments, announcements). We also updated the instructions at the top to explain how users can control these settings. Hope this starts resolving some of the issues. P