This is the P2PU Archive. If you want the current site, go to www.p2pu.org!

Open Journalism & the Open Web

My recent threads

You haven't posted any discussions yet.

Recently updated threads

Week Two Assignment Suggestion: Develop Techniques to Evaluate Articles Along Political Spectrum

Go back to: General discussion

As a consumer of news, I frequently am not aware of the hidden biases of articles, tweets and other sources of information. Imagine a college student with little sense of history listening to Glenn Beck. Without passing judgement, it is fairly obvious that Glenn's writing have  a particular slant.

 - As a user, I can determine a left-independent-right value so that I can understand the political bias of information. This covers the basic concept.

- As  a user, I can see a bias meter after I paste a block of text into a web-based form so that I can understand bias faster and more accurately than hand calculations. This covers a web-based solution.

 - As a user, I can see the word-lists associated with each bias. This story assumes that somehow a set of words indicates bias.

 - As a user, I can see a set of links associated with each bias. This story assumes a set of websites that have well-known bias (ie, fox news) are identified and if an article links to them, it affected their bias result.

Does the above make sense? Doe it already exist?

Marlon x's picture
Marlon x
Tue, 2010-09-28 15:39

I mentioned this in one of the chat sessions, i'll mention it again because I think it's pretty interesting. Not exactly the function you're imagining, but related:
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.145.9887&rep=re...

Phillip Smith's picture
Phillip Smith
Tue, 2010-09-28 17:23

"Does the above make sense?

Seems like a good fit with the assignment, and last week's lecture. :)

Phillip.

nancy cardozo's picture
nancy cardozo
Wed, 2010-09-29 19:24

double posted by accident. sorry

nancy cardozo's picture
nancy cardozo
Wed, 2010-09-29 19:08

I like this idea a lot. Here is something that might be interesting. Truthy.com (from Indiana U.) Here's what they say: "... Truthy is a system to analyze and visualize the diffusion of information on Twitter. The Truthy system evaluates thousands of tweets an hour to identify new and emerging bursts of activity around memes of various flavors. The data and statistics provided by Truthy are designed to aid in the study of social epidemics: How do memes propagate through the Twittersphere? What causes a burst of popularity?

We also plan to use Truthy to detect political smears, astroturfing, misinformation, and other social pollution. While the vast majority of memes arise in a perfectly organic manner, driven by the complex mechanisms of life on the Web, some are engineered by the shady machinery of high-profile congressional campaigns. Truthy uses a sophisticated combination of text and data mining, social network analysis, and complex networks models. To train our algorithms, we leverage crowdsourcing: we rely on users like you to flag injections of forged grass-roots activity. Therefore, click on the Truthy button when you see a suspicious meme!
System Architecture

Streaming Twitter data is acquired in real-time from the 'Gardenhose'. We match all tweets against a set of keywords to exclude tweets unlikely to contain political discussion, and extract all memes (@mentions, #hash_tags, and urls). We further isolate memes of interest by considering only those memes that have just undergone significant changes in volume, or those that account for a significant portion of the total volume (but perhaps haven't fluctuated very much). We insert these memes in the database, and use the Twitter API to get more information on each. ..." More here: http://truthy.indiana.edu/about

Michael Roberts's picture
Michael Roberts
Mon, 2010-10-04 19:08

I think you could definitely make a case for identifying "dog whistle" phrases associated with particular political stances. I think that would even be straightforward - and then you could use that to score a given text.

This is a cool idea.

Phillip Smith's picture
Phillip Smith
Mon, 2010-10-11 18:09

+1 on that idea, indeed.